Author Note: SWMS - Sugar and Vinegar is a total re-imagining of the Sex with my sister series. The Story revolves around Joshua and his family. In this version, he has a twin sister named Heather, two older sisters who are twins named Becky and Rachel and doesn't quite know who his dad is. The story starts with lots of Sex between him and his family, as well as a few friends.
Disclaimer: Any and all characters presented within this story are fictitious, and are at least 18 years of age at portrayal.
That night, I had the dream again, but this time, the woman's back wasn't to me. She was riding me so that I had a full view of her body, though I couldn't make out her face. Her body was pale, innie belly button, she was athletically built, Small breasts, maybe an A cup or a small b cup with small areolas no bigger than a quarter and nipples, fully shaven and swollen pussy, and the way it sat on my cock almost made me think I was her first. I didn't hear her say anything as she slowly rode my cock, she just had labored breathing. Before I could do anything, the dream had faded. I slowly opened my eyes to the sound of my alarm clock going off. I was on my back with Heather snuggled into my chest, and her left hand on my morning wood. She was sleepily stroking it.
"Mmmm…. Do we have to get up?" Heather asked.
"Yeah, we have to get ready for our guests," I said.
Heather's eyes opened.
"That's right, I invited Jesse over. Who did you invite?" She asked.
"Nate and his older brother," I said.
"Nate? You mean Nathan? Okay." She said looking at me a bit puzzled.
"You seem a bit puzzled," I said.
"Well, I get why you invited Nathan. He's a good friend." Heather said. "But his older brother?"
"What do you know about Nathan?" I asked.
"Not much. Keeps to himself." Heather said.
"Except for me," I said.
"Yeah, he's always hung around you," Heather said.
"Nathan has a couple of secrets you need to know," I said.
"And they are?" Heather asked.
"First, he's in an incestuous relationship with his older brother," I said.
"Oh neat, so we can make out in front of him without a thought," Heather said.
"Yeah, the second thing is, he's not a He," I said.
"So what? Nathan cross-dresses?" Heather asked.
"No…" I said, elongating the letter o.
"Then what?" Heather asked.
"Nathan's a hermaphrodite," I said.
"OH!" Heather said. "That's so cool!"
"I know. Now Nathan prefers the male pronouns, keep that in mind. However, Nathan has always wanted to be physical with a guy in a way different from the way his brother does it." I pointed out.
"How so?" Heather asked.
"Nathan's brother only sucks dick and only fucks ass," I said rather bluntly.
"Oh, so Nathan wants to get his pussy fucked," Heather said.
"He wants his brother to see that there's more than just a cock and ass, he wants his brother to enjoy all of his body," I said.
"Ah. So his brother has been ignoring his feminine half." Heather said.
"Right," I said. "I had hoped that we could have a sit-down and get Nathan to talk to his brother before their relationship turns sour and dies."
"But what if the relationship dies from the talk?" Heather asked.
"If it's love, it shouldn't. And if Scott understands that, He'll make sure that Nathan is happy by the end of the day." I pointed out. "It may not be easy for him one way or another, but I look at it this way, if I was in a similar situation, I'd want you happy with someone else if I couldn't be the guy you wanted," I added.
Heather gave me a kiss.
"You're so sweet." She said as she slowly rose up and repositioned herself.
She slowly had gotten on top of me and slid my morning wood inside her hot and wet pussy.
"You're pretty wet. Did all this get you all worked up?" I asked.
"The thought of watching Nathan's pussy getting pounded for the first time got me worked up. I'd love to watch." Heather said.
She sat up, causing the top sheet to fall around my knees. She put her legs under her and began bouncing on my cock, reminding me of the dream. It hadn't been Heather in my dream. Heather's skin was tan, and her breasts were bigger. I reached up and cupped her tits.
"You know, you're stunning when you ride my cock like this," I said.
Heather blushed as she continued riding my cock.
"You're sweet." She said.
She leaned in and kissed me passionately. I felt her pussy clench down as it convulsed. After she broke the kiss she sat back up.
"Now, should I keep going until you get off? Or did you want to still get cleaned up and ready?" She asked.
"No, I'd better get up and showered," I said.
She pulled herself off my cock which was now coated in her thick cum.
"Okay, I'll get showered after we eat. I'll go make breakfast." She said.
She climbed off the bed and headed out of the room. I had to admit, it was nice waking up next to her. I climbed out of bed and headed for the bathroom. I got showered and shaved and brushed my teeth before emerging. I opted to stay naked until after breakfast. I made my way to the table and sat down as Heather started plating up breakfast. She brought my plate out with a cup of coffee and the small bottle. She was only wearing an apron, which covered her tits and pussy from the front.
"Becky told me you need to take a dose every day," Heather said as she set the plate in front of me.
She went back and got her plate along with her cup of coffee and sat down opposite me. I took the bottle and added the dose to my coffee per usual and began eating, drinking the coffee in sips along the way, and by the end of the meal, my cock was half erect. I hadn't finished all of my coffee yet.
"You mind getting that?" I asked, without thinking twice about the situation.
"But I'm pretty much naked." Heather protested.
"If it's Nathan and his brother, I'm pretty sure his brother is gay, and Nathan said he doesn't get aroused by girls." I pointed out. "As for Jesse, she's seen you naked."
"Not exactly the point, but I guess you're right." Heather sighed as she got up.
I watched her as she walked to the door and opened it. She invited our first guests in and closed the door behind them.
"Hi, I'm Heather, Joshua's twin sister." She said to Scott.
"You two seem comfortable around each other." Scott laughed.
"Oh even before he and I got into a relationship, I would wear very little around just to tease him," Heather admitted.
I finished my coffee and stood up. I turned towards them, still naked making Nathan blush brightly. I walked over to them.
"Holy crap, you're big!" Nathan said, keeping his eyes on my cock.
"Oh come on, you've been to my practices and training for swimming," I said before giving him a hug.
As I broke the hug, he reached down and wrapped his hand around my partially erect cock.
"Are you… is this always like this?" He asked.
"No, actually. It started after I took this new medicine Becky got me to increase my virility. One of the side effects is arousal, but it's lessened if I mix the medicine with coffee." I said.
"That might actually be stopping the medicine from working." Scott pointed out.
He had a point. I made a mental note to take it with a different drink from now on.
"Good point, but let's get down to business," I said offering them a seat on the couch.
Nathan reluctantly let go of my cock before he and his brother took a seat on my couch. I took a seat in the recliner next to the couch and Heather grabbed the desk chair to join us.
Nathan was wearing white shorts and a white t-shirt with the phrase "Power is Power" across it. Scott was wearing a red t-shirt and a pair of jeans.
"I hope our nudity isn't going to be a distraction," I said. "If it is, Heather and I can get dressed."
"Only slight for me," Scott said. "It's been a good few years since I was in the same room with a naked woman and another naked guy."
"I have to admit, I'm getting turned on by both of you. I honestly want to have Josh pounding me while I fuck Heather." Nathan admitted.
"I thought you weren't into girls," Heather said.
"Normally No, or at least my cousin didn't do anything for me, but Heather, I've sort of known you as long as I've known Josh, and I've always had a thing for you," Nathan said. "You're both very attractive."
"Thank you." We said together.
"I'll add to that thought as well. Joshua, I'd love to enjoy your cock. Heather, seeing you like that is even getting me aroused." Scott said.
"Really? I thought you were only into guys." Heather said.
"No, I'm bisexual. It's just been a long time since I was with a girl." Scott explained.
Nathan gave him a shocked look.
"Then why won't you enjoy my body?" He asked.
"I do," Scott said.
"No, you enjoy fucking my ass or sucking my cock," Nathan said standing up and turning towards him. "You've never touched my tits or my pussy!"
Nathan grabbed his t-shirt and pulled it off and tossed it to the ground, revealing a white sports bra that hid his tits well. It wasn't on for long either as he pulled it off, revealing tits that were similar to Heathers. Nathan had b-cup tits, with larger areolas. His nipples were shriveled down but still not a bad size. I was stunned. I didn't expect this outburst from Nathan.
"Why don't you want to enjoy me fully?" Nathan asked almost crying.
"Because I can't." His brother said in a low tone.
"CAN'T? MORE LIKE WON'T!" Nathan yelled. "I'M PRETTY SURE JOSH WOULDN'T TURN DOWN FUCKING ME!"
"No, I wouldn't, Nathan. You're one of my best friends, but you need to calm down, this isn't about me. This is about your brother's reasoning behind not going any further than ass play." I said calmly.
Nathan stripped off his shorts, revealing his erect cock and tossed them to the ground. Fully erect, Nathan had to be about four or five inches long. His cock was thinner than mine, but no pencil dick. He grabbed his brother's hand and forced Scott to run his fingers across his outer lips. My cock throbbed, triggered to a full erection from the smell of Nathan's arousal.
"You've made me this wet easily every time we've even come close to making love, and you still won't fuck my pussy. So why?" Nathan asked, holding back his tears.
"I told you I can't," Scott said.
"Why not?" Nathan asked as he started to cry. "FUCKING TELL ME!"
"BECAUSE IF I MADE LOVE TO YOU THE WAY YOU WANTED, I DON'T KNOW IF I COULD STOP ENOUGH TO KEEP YOU FROM GETTING KNOCKED UP!" Scott blurted out.
"Pregnancy? That's what you're worried about?" Heather asked walking over to them.
She got Nathan to sit down.
"Yeah. The last girl I was with before Nathan started got pregnant. She had a miscarriage, which was a good thing because she was a total skank." Scott explained as Heather kneeled down in front of them. "I can't risk getting you knocked up. You're a hermaphrodite, and we don't know if you can even have kids, but we can't get you tested on the premise that You and I are sleeping together… and if we decided to do it, and even if I used a condom, there's a chance. Even a slight one, that you could get knocked up. Not everyone knows your condition. Josh, and his family, yeah they know, and they're cool with it, but what about others. I don't want you treated badly at school cause you're different." Scott sobbed. "You already have a tough time hiding it."
"So why not stop hiding it? My friends would be supportive. Joshua's too." Heather pointed out.
"But I barely know them," Nathan said.
"That doesn't matter. You didn't have a say in the way you are. You were born this way. And your body is breathtaking. Scott is lucky to have you." I said.
"I can call them all over right now, and we can come clean about all of this. None of them would have an issue with it, I can guarantee that." Heather added.
"Really?" Scott asked.
"Really," I said. "If they did, they wouldn't be friends of mine."
"Okay, so that fixes that. I'm willing to stop hiding if I've got even you two supporting me, so what do you say, Scott? Do you want to grab a condom and take my virginity?" Nathan asked.
"Right now? In front of them?" Scott asked.
This time it was Scott's turn to blush.
"Yeah. Why not? I mean, Josh has been my best friend forever. He's known what I was since we were ten and my period first hit." Nathan said. "Like I said before, I'm pretty sure he wouldn't turn down the chance at fucking me."
Scott stared at his brother then turned to me.
"Would you guys mind if we put a bow on this here?" Scott asked. "And I hate to ask but do you have any condoms?"
Heather answered it by walking over to Scott and undoing his button on his pants. She pulled out his semi hard cock and marveled at it.
"Hope you don't mind." She said to Nathan before plunging it into her mouth.
"You've got your answer, and I think I have some condoms," I said as I started to get up.
Nathan got up with me as Heather was blowing Scott, and followed me into the bedroom.
"Listen, I'm sorry for putting this all on the two of you," Nathan said.
"Nathan, my girlfriend is out there blowing your boyfriend. I think I'm cool with it." I said as I headed to my sock drawer and opened it.
I pulled out a few condoms and turned back towards him. I stopped in front of him and took a moment to check him out. Besides a little hair on his cock, his body was very similar to Heather's body.
"Are you sure you're ready for this step though? I mean losing your virginity?" I asked.
"One way or another I was planning on losing it today," Nathan said. "I knew you wouldn't turn me down if I asked you to do it."
"No, I wouldn't," I said. "But that's because you're one of my best friends. And if it was eating at you that much, I couldn't let you suffer."
"Thanks." He said, leaning in and kissing me on the cheek. "Now did you want me to get you off before losing my virginity?" I asked.
"Nah, Heather will probably have that covered," I said as I handed him the condoms.
He took the condoms and we walked out to the living room. Heather pulled Scott's cock out of her mouth.
"Holy shit, I'm about to burst," Scott said.
"That was fast," Nathan said. "You've never been that ready that fast."
"She's really good at giving head." I pointed out as I wrapped my arms around Nathan's waist.
"But I want to cum at the same time as you." Nathan protested.
"I can help with that," I said.
"Really?" Nathan asked.
"If it's alright with Scott, I'll be happy to eat you out," I said.
"Be my guest," Scott said.
"Hey! No fair!" Heather said. "I wanted to suck him too." She protested.
"You… you do?" Nathan said in disbelief.
"Sure," Heather said with a giggle.
She crawled over to him and practically inhaled his cock as I moved my hands onto his hips. As Heather began sucking his cock, I slowly moved my right hand down behind him and between his legs to his pussy. I gently stroked it as she continued. Nathan let out a loud moan from the pleasure he was receiving. Scott was slowly jerking his own cock as he watched his hermaphrodite sibling being worked over a bit. I spread Nathan's pussy lips apart with my index and ring finger and slowly inserted my middle finger into his tight snatch. As I put my left hand on his left tit and began massaging it, he turned his head.
"I've never felt anything like this, it's overwhelming." He cooed as I slowly began thrusting my finger in and out of him.
"Just warn us when you're getting close," I whispered.
"I don't know if I can last long though," Nathan said.
"You don't have to hold out," I said.
"HEATHER, STOP." He warned.
Heather stopped and pulled her mouth off his cock, as I slowly removed my hands. I didn't want to push him over the edge. Scott quickly removed his pants the rest of the way. Nathan rushed over to the couch.
"Scott. I'm not going to lie. I want to feel you cum inside my pussy on our first time." Nathan said. "But if you're still unsure."
"Nate, if you want this, I can't tell you no. Not anymore. Mom and Dad have already accepted what we're doing and they understand. So if you want to do this unprotected; I'm willing." Scott told Nathan.
The two of them shared a passionate kiss as Nathan took his brother's cock, and positioned it at his opening. Nathan lowered himself onto it, impaling himself and taking his virginity. Once Scott was fully situated inside Nathan, Nathan only took a moment or two to get used to it, bounced once and then they both let out a satisfied groan. Scott had cum inside Nathan, and Nathan's cock convulsed, shooting his seed onto his brother's chest. There was a light knock on the door and Heather got up. She went to the door, and pulled Jesse inside quickly and closed it.
"You just missed watching all the fun," Heather said.
Jesse looked Heather up and down, seeing that she was wearing nothing but her apron.
"You're… naked… mostly." Jesse said looking at Heather.
Jesse then looked over to me. She had bit her lower lip as she had looked at me. Then she looked at the two on the couch. Her eyes went wide as she realized who the girl was on top.
"Nathan?" Jesse said. "You're a? Wait… both? A hermaphrodite?"
"Yeah," Nathan said. "And this is my boyfriend and older brother Scott."
"Oh wow. That's a lot to take in." Jesse said sitting down in the recliner.
"Are you okay?" I asked.
"I walk into your house, Nathan turns out to be a hermaphrodite who just had sex with its brother, Heather is naked, and from the drool on her chin, had been sucking dick, your dick is dry but your fingers are wet, so I'm guessing it was you two getting them ready, and oh yeah you're naked too, but with the biggest cock I've seen," Jesse said. "I'm just trying to process it all."
"Okay, I'll go get dressed, I don't want to make you uncomfortable," I said.
I left the room, headed for my bedroom. I entered my bedroom and headed for the dresser as I heard the door close behind me. I looked over my shoulder to see Jesse standing there biting her lower lip. I turned towards her. Jessica Monica Talberi was her full name. She was our age and had short blonde hair with green eyes. She was a couple inches shorter than Heather and I and had a more plump body. Now, she wasn't exactly overweight… not really, she just had a more curvy figure than Heather. She was dressed in a large t-shirt that hung off her tits and went down to just above her knees. I turned back to my dresser and grabbed my cock rings. Now was as good as time as any to have them on standby.
"Listen, I didn't mean for you to rush off like that," Jesse said.
"No, but I understand how that can all be a bit overwhelming. You just walked in on basically a scene out of a porno." I said as I started searching for a pair of shorts in my dresser.
"It was a bit overwhelming, and seeing you in the fray was a little unnerving. I understand that you were just helping a friend. I mean Nathan and you have been close since you were little." Jesse said. "Kind of the way Heather and I have been."
"Are you saying you'd want Heather to get you ready to lose your virginity?" I asked without turning around.
"You know that isn't fair," Jesse said in a low tone.
"What isn't?" I asked, being oblivious as I often had been at that age.
"I've been spoon fed all of that stuff about staying a virgin until I was married, and only sleeping with my husband and all that kind of thing thru church," Jesse said. "I don't even believe in the stories in the bible. I only go because I'm forced to by my parents." She added. "And here I am, standing in a room with a naked guy, one that I'm attracted to. He's got a mega boner, and if I were to do anything… ANYTHING… I would either be a tease, or be a slut, or a harlot, or whatever they call girls like me who fuck before marriage." She said starting to cry.
I stopped digging thru the dresser and turned towards her as she sat down on my bed and put her face in her hands. I put my cock rings on before walking over and sitting down next to her.
"Listen, you just admitted you liked me right?" I asked as she cried next to me.
She pulled her face from her hands and wiped her tears before nodding.
"So… my opinion matters?" I asked.
"Yes." She said.
"And do you think that Heather is a slut? Or Easy? Or a Harlot?" I asked.
"No, but how many times has she had sex?" Jesse asked.
"Let's ask," I said.
I called out to Heather who was happy to enter the room, still in her apron, which barely hid the wetness on her legs. She had been watching Nate and Scott go at it, and it showed.
"Heather, how many guys have you fucked?" I asked.
"One." She said.
"And how many times have you had sex with him?" I asked.
"Three times." She answered.
"Now, Jesse, do you still think that if you had sex, you'd be a slut or easy or a harlot when you don't consider your best female friend who has had sex with one guy, three times, and plans on having more with him, one?" I asked.
"No, I guess not," Jesse said.
"Neither would I. Heather how about you?" I asked.
"Nope. What you do with your body is your business." Heather said.
"Thanks but I have a couple questions for you, Heather." Jesse sniffled.
"Ask away," Heather said.
"I really like J.T.… would you get mad if he and I were to?" She asked.
"Can I watch?" Heather asked with a giggle.
"Um… okay… if it's alright with him…" Jesse said.
I turned Jesse's head towards me with my right hand and kissed her passionately on the lips. She returned the kiss. We broke the kiss after a moment or two and she blushed.
"Wow. I… um…" She started to say, but I could tell what happened.
The smell in the air from her added arousal was overwhelming. I have to admit, during this next part, it was sort of like I was on autopilot for a minute or two. The next thing I remember was hovering over Jesse, who had her shirt and bikini top pulled up, revealing her beautiful tits, and her bikini bottoms pushed aside with my cock buried to the hilt inside her. She let out a long moan as my cock came to a rest against her cervix.
"Oh god yes." She moaned.
Her pussy began milking my cock again as I left it there.
"I'm sorry, I'm not sure what came over me. Are you okay?" I asked, as looked down at her body.
Her tits were wonderful, nice, big, and just a bit of sag. Her areolas were larger than I had imagined, but I was fine with that. I massaged her tits as I awaited her answer.
"Well, let's see… what do you think about me? And my body?" She asked.
"You're beautiful, inside and out. I probably don't have to tell you what I think of your body, considering my cock is now deep in your pussy because the smell of your arousal overtook me." I said.
My cock throbbed in agreement.
"As for you on the inside, I saw the sorrow in your eyes when you were talking about the fight between what you had been taught and what you wanted to do. You need to be more confident though." I said.
She kissed me softly on the lips.
"That is what I hoped I'd hear." She said with a smile. "I'm glad you were my first." She cooed at me.
"Honestly, I'm sorry that it happened so fast," I said. "Heather, can you get me a condom?" I asked. "I want to make sure that I'm not cumming inside Jesse unless she wants me to."
"Sure," Heather said before walking over to my dresser.
She pulled out a condom from one of my drawers and walked it over to me. I took it from her, and slowly pulled my cock from Jesse's freshly deflowered pussy, indicated by the blood running down her taint, and put the condom on. Before I could slip back into her, she stopped me.
"Wait." She said.
"Okay," I said.
She sat up and took off her shirt and bikini top, letting me get a better view of her beautiful d-cup breasts. She was a 36D cup with small nipples and areolas the size of a half dollar. They were beautiful and had a bit of sag to them, but not overly much. You probably know the kind. Full and wonderful, but not like it was two sacks of liquid held on by skin.
"Listen, I'm probably going to regret saying this because you probably don't feel the same. I've had a crush on you for a while now, and what just happened, even though it wasn't something that we had planned out, was something I would've given anything to feel." She started. "I've fantasized about somehow seducing you, having a relationship, starting a family, and even making love. It's gotten me through some depressing times, and though you probably don't feel for me like that, what just happened isn't a bad thing in my mind, it's a dream come true. I know that is probably never going to be possible. I'm nothing more than a disgusting cow. I'm overweight and I have these huge… UDDERS on my chest to boot!" She said, grabbing her tits harshly as she said the last bit. "I wouldn't blame you for not wanting me, nor wanting to acknowledge what we did… even as an accident." She released her grip on her tits.
"Why are you so negative about the situation?" I asked.
"Because You were just overcome by instinct and probably only want to finish because you feel bad," Jesse said.
"I don't feel bad about what I just did," I said.
I reached out and undid the ties for her bikini bottom.
"I got to take the virginity of a beautiful young lady, who just happens to be one of my best friends. She's been by my side and supporting me since Kindergarten, and if I hadn't been so oblivious, I probably would've seen the signs and asked her out long ago." I said.
I pulled her bikini bottom away, revealing her entire lower section. I got down and lowered my face to her freshly deflowered pussy and took in the scent that had overwhelmed me earlier, committing it to memory, before I spread her pussy lips and began licking and sucking on her clit. She let out a moan from the pleasure I gave her, only to grab me by the back of my head and pull me away.
"God Dammit, J.T.! Fuck me already! Fuck me Hard!" She cursed at me.
Not wanting to disappoint her, I got her to let go before I repositioned myself and slowly slid my throbbing cock into her tight pussy. Upon burying myself to the hilt, her pussy tightened as a hot liquid enveloped my sheathed cock, and she let out a long moan. I felt my cock convulse at this, but I didn't cum thanks to the rings. It was nearly impossible to thrust after my cock settled down a little, but I managed to thrust once, and hard, causing her to let out another moan. This time her juices squirted out and began running down my balls.
"God, J.T! I NEED IT HARDER!" She moaned.
I finally found the groove I needed to fuck her as she wanted and began thrusting hard, harder than I had with anyone prior, with her pussy tightly gripping me as I did. With each thrust another loud moan and every few thrusts, my cock would convulse. Finally, after about five minutes of this, I felt her pussy tighten again, and more hot liquid enveloped my still sheathed cock. She let out the loudest moan yet.
When she calmed down a bit, she just laid there panting heavily.
"Damn." She panted. "Just damn… please tell me you're single." She asked.
I felt my cock convulse again. Though short this time, fucking her was very enjoyable, and I hated to tell her what she didn't want to hear.
"Yes. I have a girlfriend." I said.
"So you just cheated on her with me?" Jesse asked.
"No, we're in an open relationship," I explained.
"So the best I can hope to be is a side piece?" Jesse asked as tears welled up in her eyes.
Heather climbed onto the bed next to Jesse. She had taken off her apron while watching Jesse and I go at it, and I could see that her pussy was incredibly aroused. She pulled Jesse into a passionate kiss.
"Absolutely not. If you want to date Josh, or even fuck him on a regular basis, I'm cool with it." Heather cooed after the kiss. "Watching the two of you fuck was the hottest thing I've ever seen, and I just watched a hermaphrodite lose her virginity to his brother."
I slowly pulled my throbbing cock from Jesse's tight pussy. My cock was leaking precum, not just a small bubble, but it was dripping into the condom. After I was sure it was just dripping, I pulled the condom off and pulled off the rings. I got in between Heather's legs as Jesse put the hints together.
"Wait, you're dating Heather?" She asked as I slipped my cock into Heather's pussy.
"He sure is." Heather moaned as I began thrusting my hips against hers.
"Heather, I'm about to cum, and it's going to be huge," I said.
"Good, you haven't gotten off yet today, and I don't want you all backed up." Heather cooed.
"Here it comes!" I groaned before cumming lightly inside her.
A few more thrusts and I was done cumming. Frankly, I was disappointed in myself for this.
"Hey, that's not good," Heather said as I pulled out of her. "That's nowhere near the normal amount."
"I've still got more built up, I can feel it," I explained.
"Then use me," Jesse said. "Fuck every one of my holes. Cum in all of them. I may not be your girlfriend, but I'm not going to be a bad lover for either of you."
"Really? You're sure?" Heather asked.
"You'd better sit on my face so I can eat you out, while your brother gets off," Jessi said with a smirk.
I repositioned myself and slid back inside Jessi as Heather sat on her face and started to get my cum licked out of her pussy. I began fucking her like I had before, though I have to admit, this time, Jesse didn't feel as tight. Had she loosened up just from watching me pump my cum inside Heather? Or had it been something else? My thrusting was forceful, but kind of automatic as I seemed to be enthralled with her enjoying my twin sister's pussy. Finally, after about five minutes, my cock began to twitch, and my balls began to contract, snapping me out of my stupor.
"Oh God. It's going to be a big one! I'm cumming!" I moaned.
My cock spasmed before I began cumming deep inside her unprotected womb. She pushed my sister up and looked at me.
"J.T., slowly pull out, clamp off, and shove it in my ass." She said. "Don't worry, I've been prepping for this." She added with a smile.
I did as she asked, pulling my cock out, and holding it, but my cock didn't like it. She lifted her ass off the bed, giving me the perfect position. I positioned myself, and entered her ass, releasing my vice grip on my cock, letting it finish spilling its seed in her ass. Heather got off of her.
"I'm gonna have to start prepping to allow him in mine one of these days." Heather giggled. "And you do a good job eating pussy." She said to Jesse.
"Thanks. I wouldn't mind doing it again. I loved the taste of both of you." Jesse said with a smile. "J.T.? Can you clamp off again, I want the rest in my mouth." She asked.
I wasn't about to deny her, though I thought it a bit gross. But she knew what she was asking. I pulled out, and clamped off as I did so again, before moving to her head, and offering her my cock. She took it into her mouth and I released my vice grip again. She started swallowing down my remaining cum, only letting a bit gush out of her mouth which dripped down to her tits and stomach. As my cock finally stopped spasming, she pulled it from her mouth and let the last few spurts shoot onto her tits and stomach. My cock was still hard and ready to go after all of that, though it was a bit sore now.
"There. You've had my mouth, my ass, and my pussy. You've also covered me in your seed." She said.
She looked over at Heather.
"Anytime you want your pussy eaten, I'd be happy to oblige." She said with a smile. "I love you both so much, thank you for this."
"Jesse. I can't express how much I care for you, and the fact that you wanted us for your first time is just… wow." I said.
"Ditto here," Heather said. "We love you. Anytime you want, anytime you need to be fucked or made love to, just let us know."
The two began making out as I heard a slight moan come from the doorway. I turned to see Nate standing there, with his phallus in his hand. It was fully erect at around 4 inches or so, and he was softly jerking it as he watched them making out. His eyes were locked on Heather and Jesse making out. Maybe he wasn't quite set on being only into guys as he had thought. I looked him over as he jerked his cock. I got up off the bed and slowly walked over to him. I stood next to him.
"That was so hot," Nate said.
"How much did you get to enjoy?" I asked.
"I walked in when you were just starting with Heather." He said.
"So you got to enjoy the show. Good." I said as I reached down and felt his dripping pussy. "Feels like you want more," I said.
"Yeah, but Scott passed out on me," Nate said.
"If you'd like, I could fuck you." I offered.
"I would, Josh, but I'm not in an open relationship like you," Nate said.
"Okay. Let me go see if I can't wake him up." I said as I removed my hand.
If he was set on it, I wasn't going to force the issue. He wanted to remain loyal to his boyfriend and I wasn't about to mess with that. I walked past him and headed out to the living room to find Scott slumbering on the couch. I woke him gently, and let him know that Nate was still in need of relief. He gave me a brief look of disbelief.
"But if he needs relief, why didn't you just fuck his brains out?" Scott asked.
"Believe it or not, Nate doesn't want to," I said.
"What? I know for a fact that he wants you." Scott said.
"Not more than he wants to stay loyal to your relationship." I pointed out.
"Listen, Josh, I don't want you to take this as a free pass, but if Nate wants it, I'd let you fuck him until you both were worn out, and by the look of that beautiful erection you have going on, I'm guessing it would take a while," Scott said.
"I figured you might say that, but Scott, Nathan is one of my best friends. I'm not going to force him to do anything that he has a problem with, and that includes screwing." I said.
"You're sure?" Scott asked as we gathered up their clothing.
I handed Scott the clothing as we walked towards the bedroom. We entered to see Nathan standing there staring as Heather and Jesse made out. His right hand was softly jerking his hard cock and his left was teasing his pussy.
"Nate, why don't you just let Josh fuck you? I mean, I know you want to feel that huge cock of his deep inside you, and filling up your womb with as much cum as he obviously put into Jesse." Scott said.
"You don't understand do you?" Nate asked.
"I understand that I can't seem to satisfy you fully today," Scott said. "And I'm totally cool with him being there to satisfy you when I can't."
"But Nate would feel bad," I said.
Nate's eyes lit up.
"It's not like he doesn't know I'm there for him, or that you're happy to let me fuck him. He would feel like scum doing it, even if you let him, right now, to steal away the first day of you two really making love." I said. "He's not ready to change my relationship with him that much yet. And I'm okay with that. If he ever decides he wants me to fuck him, or make love to him, I'll happy bury my cock so deep inside him, and give him as much or as little cum inside him as he wants." I stated. "but right now, he doesn’t want that, and I respect his decision." I finally added.
"Wow," Nate said looking at me.
"I hope that doesn't change things between us," I added softly.
"Oh, it does," Nate said. "I think I just got a huge crush on my best friend."
He gave me a soft kiss on the cheek.
"Now, I think Scott and I are going to go get dressed and head home," Nate said. "I'll see you in school," Nate added.
With that, he grabbed his brother by the hand and walked out of the room.
"I think we need to get a bit cleaned up," Heather said, getting up off the bed.
"Oh yeah, definitely." Jesse agreed.
"Jesse, I got to ask. Your pussy was so fucking tight, how?" I asked.
"Oh I have these special beads I put into my pussy, and it tightens from them. I've also been prepping my ass for you to fuck for the past few months. So I was more than ready for today." She said with a smile.
She got off the bed, the two girls giggled then headed out of my room leaving me alone. I grabbed a washcloth from the top of my dresser and headed to the kitchen to clean the spunk off my cock as the girls did their thing. I decided to go out back while they did. I got comfortable on a lawn lounger and ended up falling asleep. No kidding, I passed right the fuck out. I was awoken sometime later by a very talented mouth, sucking and licking at my cock. I opened my eyes to see that the sun was going down and Jesse was the one enjoying my cock.
"Hey, Handsome," Jesse said after giving the length of my shaft a long lick. "I wanted to give you a goodbye blowjob before I left. That way you might not just turn me into another notch in your bedpost." She said before climbing on top of me.
My cock was rock hard again and she was back in her bikini. I stared into her longing eyes before we exchanged a very passionate kiss. As we kissed, I reached in between us and positioned my cock. I slowly thrusted it inside her pussy, making her gasp.
"Another notch?" I asked as she stared into my eyes. "You really think that little of yourself?" I asked.
I started thrusting in and out of her as she moaned on top of me.
"I plan on fucking you every chance you give me, and making love to you whenever we have enough time," I said.
"But… why…would…you…want…me?" She panted.
I picked up the speed and strength of my thrusts.
"Because you want me, and Heather's cool with it, and Dammit Jesse, you need to remember that you're one of my best friends, and that means I'd do anything for you. I told you before that I would've tried dating you had I not been so oblivious before." I said.
"Tell… me…" She panted.
Her pussy tightened and she let out a loud moan.
"Your pussy is so tight…" I moaned.
"Just for you." She cooed.
"Your tits are beautiful," I added as I groped them.
"I love you, J.T." She moaned.
"I'm going to cum," I warned her.
"Inside me, deep inside me." She begged.
One final slam of my cock in her pussy and it erupted. Well, my cock erupted, her pussy gushed. She let out a long moan from the feeling. After our orgasms subsided, she rested her head on my chest. I put my arms around her.
"J.T., I've got a confession." She said.
"What is it?" I asked.
"You're going to be mad." She said.
"Just tell me," I said.
"I'm not protected." She said. "You could've knocked me up today. Are you alright with that?" She asked.
"Yeah. Heather's never been on protection." I said, "And I'm cool with that."
"I love you, J.T." She said.
"I love you too, Jesse," I said.
Well, it was true, she was more than just a fuck buddy, I loved her as much as I did my other sexual partners. Each of them loved me differently, but they all wanted a nice romantic life with me, the difference was, I couldn't have one with most of them. Not really anyways. Not one where I could leave the house without any real precautions and have a nice date with them. Jesse continued cuddling into me until my cock deflated and fell from her pussy. She then got up and helped me up, and we headed inside. She got the rest of her clothing on, and I showed her out. I headed to my room, where Heather was waiting. She was laying across my bed, completely naked. She had cleaned up the sheets and the pillow cases. She also added the pillows from her room.
"You had fun today." She said with a smirk.
"You did too. Plenty of cocks to suck today, huh?" I asked.
"Yeah, and a nice day off from getting my pussy overly pounded. I have to admit, I'm still a bit sore from all the sex over the past week or so." Heather said.
"So, do you need to relax tonight?" I asked.
"I'm already pretty relaxed. Let's get some sleep. Considering our last day off is tomorrow, I think we're going to probably enjoy it." Heather said with a smile.
Little did I know, she was all too right. The next day would be enjoyable. I got into bed, as she cuddled into my chest. She reached for my cock and felt the goo on it. She let go, licked her hand clean and then cleaned up all the juices off my cock by giving me an excellent blow job, getting me fully hard again. She then got on top of me and slipped me inside her. She laid down on top of me and clapped off the lights. We were hitting the hay early, but we needed to be up extra early to get in the mindset for school. We slowly slipped into slumber.